26 March, 2010 – 21:31
Talking of the avant garde, we went to see one of the most challenging films I’ve ever watched at the London Lesbian and Gay Film Festival last night.
The film was Uncle David, a new 95 minute improvised dark comedy offering from the Avant-Garde Alliance, which includes the fabulous and acerbic RVT regular David Hoyle and porn star Ashley Ryder.
It was shot over three days at some beautifully bleak locations on the Isle of Sheppey, with an entirely improvised script, every performance the first and only take. And it looks beautiful for a film made on a budget of £1,800.
The film is about the close sexual relationship between middle aged uncle David and his teenage nephew Ashley. It’s a deeply believable and unsettling love story. David Hoyle plays a character very like his cabaret persona, dispensing by turns bitter sociological musings on the fucked up state of humanity and optimistic exhortations to create an anarchist paradise, while Ashley plays an earnest, almost childlike, young man who turns to his witty uncle for spiritual, political and social guidance of every kind.
As the film progresses you realise they have visited Sheppey to prepare for something, they are going “to release” Ashley from this world that isn’t worthy of their unconventional love. At first I took it to mean that he was going to send Ashley off into adulthood, but then you begin to feel an awful darkness brooding beneath the surface. David and Ashley have a mutual loving pact to kill Ashley, to “set him free” while he is young and untainted by any compromise with society, perhaps to heal the world, or to escape from it. What feels at first like a very humorous, eccentric, English film slowly twists into a nightmare; I desperately wanted it to end some other way.
For me, it wasn’t so much this scenario that gave the film its brutal impact, the plot itself is not so extreme, it was more my emotional engagement with the relationship between the two main characters. Ashley is an extremely attractive actor, he’s a great porn star after all, but his character is also very appealing: boyish, open and earnest. The film shows what must be a powerful factor in intergenerational relationships: the intense combination of the caring protectiveness of parental love and the electric intensity of sexual love.
This film was also entirely improvised, and that gives it even more power. Seeing improvised films always reminds me of what strong believable characters you can create through improvisation. Like the characters from a Mike Leigh film, David and Ashley feel deeply genuine, their love for each other is tangible, heart stirring and utterly convincing. Ashley Ryder said in the Q&A after the film that they had been improvising these characters for six months, talking to each other in character, writing letters, and so on. So the three days of filming on Sheppey was the creative culmination of this intense months long improvisation session. Hence Ashley’s death pact is like an unstoppable whirlpool that draws you into its horrible depths.
The death is really drawn out as well, David kills Ashley with three lethal injections, presumably overdoses of something like heroin, and I was just praying for it to end, but it goes on and on! A couple of people left the cinema after the first injection, but most of the audience seemed to be able to handle it. Many of us seemed to be RVT regulars, stalwarts of David Hoyle’s various entertaining and challenging cabaret performances in Vauxhall.
I got the feeling that the film had emerged from the gay cabaret scene, this tradition with its own morality forged in the face of massive homophobic repression. The film has the creative, bitter defiance of cabaret, resisting mainstream social attitudes and giving visibility to identities that are considered taboo. I think what I’m left with after seeing it, is broadly agreeing with its implied disgust and frustration with mainstream society, but utterly unable to identify with the idea that the extinguishing of a life could ever be a creative response to that.
posted in film | no comments »